Central Market, Wegmans, Trader Joe’s Score Best in Consumer Rankings

Competitive pricing was the most important reason for shoppers to select a grocery store
Photograph courtesy of Wegmans

Regional chains outperform national chains in customer satisfaction, according to the Consumer Reports 2018 Supermarkets Survey by nonprofit member organization Consumer Reports Survey Research Group (CR).

Of the 96 stores rated, five regional grocers earned top marks, including Dallas-based Central Market; Rochester, N.Y.-based Wegmans Food Markets; Cleveland-based Heinen's Grocery Store; Encino, Calif.-based Gelson’s Markets; and Tewksbury, Mass.-based Market Basket. National chain Trader Joe’s, based in Monrovia, Calif., also earned CR’s top overall satisfaction score.

Chains that received the lowest ratings include Philadelphia-based Acme Markets; West Bridewater, Mass.-based Shaw’s Supermarkets; Bentonville, Ark.-based Walmart Supercenter; Williamsville, N.Y.-based Tops Friendly Markets; and New York-based Key Food.

The survey gauged responses from 75,065 CR members who provided ratings of the one or two stores they visit most, including supermarkets, warehouse clubs and supercenters. Respondents rated stores on 13 attributes including cleanliness, price, food quality and variety, checkout speed and staff helpfulness, assortment of healthy options and locally produced foods, and a variety of international and multicultural items.

Competitive Pricing Trumps All

Price was ranked as the most important factor that shoppers consider when selecting a grocery store. The survey found that, among those who quit shopping at a particular store, one of the most common reasons stated was that it was too expensive.

Trader Joe’s and Market Basket received top marks on competitive pricing, followed by Crest Foods, Costco Wholesale Corp., Fareway Stores, WinCo Foods Inc., Aldi, Woodman’s Markets, Lidl, Grocery Outlet and Save-A-Lot.

One survey respondent noted that, in addition to its private brand items, Trader Joe’s offers low prices on even name-brand items compared to competitors.

Conversely, stores that were deemed too expensive and received the lowest ratings on competitive pricing include Key Food, Shaw’s, Acme Markets, Randalls, Giant Eagle, King Kullen Grocery Co., Whole Foods Market, Coborn’s, Roche Bros. Supermarkets, Haggen Northwest Fresh, Lunds & Byerlys, The Fresh Market and New Seasons Market.

Tops spokesperson Kathleen Sautter noted the negative impact that the company’s recently completed Chapter 11 restructuring might have had on consumers’ perception of the store.

“After having emerged with a stronger balance sheet, we can now better focus on what customers want and need, invest back into our stores with remodels, and have more aggressive offerings,” Sautter said. “We are thankful that during the restructuring process our customer base remained dedicated Tops shoppers, and we will continue to work hard to maintain their loyalty.”

Gelson’s Market also received the lowest mark on pricing, despite its overall top score in customer satisfaction—indicating that in some instances, consumers are willing to spend more money for higher-quality product assortment.

Assortment, Produce Quality Are Key

Following price, produce quality and a store’s variety of products were among the most important reasons survey respondents chose where to shop. Known for their quality standards for fresh foods, Central Market and Wegmans were the only stores to excel in both produce quality and product variety, including selection of healthy options, local items and assortment of international and multicultural foods.

Heinen’s, Gelson’s, New Seasons Market, Lunds & Byerlys and Fresh Thyme Farmers Market also earned top scores in produce quality.

Notably, not a single grocer received a top score for its price of organic options. However, several stores received high marks, including national brands Aldi, Costco and Trader Joe’s, as well as regional chains Fresh Thyme, Grocery Outlet, Natural Grocers and Woodman’s.

Burt Flickinger III, managing director of Strategic Resource Group, a New York-based consulting company that specializes in retail and consumer products, said a lack of partnerships between retailers and organic food companies, a shortage of certified organic farmland and a lack of truckers nationwide are all factors that contribute to the high price of organic foods.

"Even if you have a great organic crop in Southern California, the price to get a truckload to Philadelphia is now $5,500, from $2,500 a few years ago," he said.

Overall, Central Market, Trader Joe’s and Costco received the survey’s highest marks for quality. 

Walmart, Whole Foods Falter

Just 11 out of the 96 stores rated received below-average scores for employee helpfulness and attentiveness, but Walmart Supercenter was the only grocer to receive the lowest mark for this attribute.

“This rating is not one that we ever want to have, but it is also not indicative of the overall program,” said Molly Blakeman, a Walmart spokesperson. “We appreciate [the] feedback; it’s going to help us make the service better overall.”

Despite receiving top marks in nearly every category, particularly for meat and poultry quality, Whole Foods also faltered on overall customer satisfaction due to consumers’ perception of high prices, including those on its organic offerings. The retailer recently employed a third round of price cuts under parent company Amazon, stating it would lower prices by an average of 20% as well as expand benefits for Prime members. However, public reception of the cuts has been mixed, with some reports indicating the price cuts resulted in savings of as little as 5 cents.



More from our partners